A few months ago, our cheap Philips DVD player started having trouble reading discs (especially dual-layer discs, where it would freeze when changing layers and then we'd have to finish watching the DVD on the 15-inch PowerBook). I started looking to get a replacement, but I realized it would be sort of silly to buy a nice new DVD player to use with our extremely cruddy CRT television—one we bought the day we moved in together over three years ago based on the following requirements: Cheap, doesn't look completely like ass, is twenty-seven inches and has a screen that isn't completely rounded—especially since I've been wanting to move to HDTV for quite a while now. And, to top it off, I've been dying to get my hands on the XBOX 360, which pumps out a native HD signal. So, instead of looking for a new DVD player, I started looking for a new TV. And I finally picked one.
We ended up getting a 42-inch Sony Wega rear-project three LCD TV. That's a lot of words that might not mean much, but the gist of it is, it's big, it's pretty, and it's such a huge improvement that I can't even remember what it was like to watch TV on our old box. I chose LCD rear-projection because I didn't care much about extreme thinness in my television—I'm never going to hang it on the wall, and I have a decent amount of space, so the TV being six inches deep doesn't bother me, especially when that six inches saves me a thousand dollars when compared with the LCD version of the TV. The viewing angle is narrower with this TV than with an LCD or plasma, but again—we only watch the TV in certain ways. Instead of trying to buy a TV that fit all sorts of situations I don't have, I bought one that fit the way we watch TV and what we need and I'm thrilled with the choice.
Once I had chosen the new TV, buying a new DVD player was much easier. I went with a Sony DVD player with progressive scan and HDMI output, and chose a player based on the quality of its up-conversion to 720p (my TV's native format), since we'll be watching a lot of standard definition DVD movies on our high definition television. The player was actually quite inexpensive (I was expecting to pay several hundred dollars but only spent one and change), and it looks great even when playing older DVDs. My test cases—King Kong, The Matrix and Saving Private Ryan—all look fantastic on the bigger screen. They're not completely sharp—such is the reality of up-converting 720x480 to 1280x720—but the larger widescreen presentation more than makes up for it. Watching the New York City scenes in King Kong almost gives you vertigo at times.
Rounding out the entertainment overhaul is the XBOX 360 which is, in a word, marvelous. I had the original XBOX, which I later sold, and I liked it a lot. I didn't think I would (based on my intense hatred for Microsoft), but once I had it I truly loved it. XBOX Live! was so well done and seamless, the games were unique and looked great, and I really had fun with it. I sold it more than a year ago to take a break from gaming until the next-generation consoles came out, and ever since the 360 was released I've been yearning to get it. The XBOX 360 is effectively everything that was good about the original XBOX, multiplied by fifty. The XBOX Live! functionality is more integrated with the system, the XBOX marketplace is a great idea (and actually works!), and, my god, it looks fantastic in HD. While it may be true that you don't need an HD TV to enjoy the 360, it certainly helps! An added bonus to the 360 is that, hopefully, sometime down the road, Microsoft will sell an HD-DVD add-on for the box that's cheaper than a stand-alone HD-DVD player and we'll be able to use that to play HD DVDs.
The only weak point of our new entertainment set-up is Time Warner Cable. Their HD service isn't all that great. There aren't a ton of channels in HD, and those that are aren't always nearly as crisp or brilliant as one would hope. Watching older re-runs in 4:3 isn't as bothersome as one would think (the new TV in side-bar mode is effectively as large as our old TV), but it would be nice to see channels like Cartoon Network and Comedy Central move to HD, and shows like The Simpsons and Family Guy really need to make the move as well. Of course, shows like 24 and Smallville look great in HD and, perhaps not surprisingly, the Discovery Channel in HD is really fun to watch. If anything, having an HD TV makes you realize just how terrible standard definition TV really is. When you see an SD commercial while watching 24, it's hard not to laugh at just how bad TV used to look.
I put up a few pictures of the new setup on Flickr.